Judge Bars Genetically Modified Sugar Beets

By THE NEW YORK TIMES

Published: August 13, 2010

• • Digg
  • Mixx
  • MySpace
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Permal

A federal judge issued a ban Friday on any future planting of genetically modified sugar beets, potentially imperiling nearly all of the United States crop.

Enlarge This Image

Bernd Roselieb for the International Herald Tribune.

A sugar beet.

Related

Ruling Banning the Planting of Genetically Modified Sugar Beets (pdf)

Judge Jeffrey S. White of United States District Court in San Francisco ruled that the Department of Agriculture had failed to conduct a required environmental impact statement before approving the genetically modified beets. Such beets now account for about 95 percent of the nation’s sugar beet production and nearly half of the sugar produced.
It is unclear how quickly the Department of Agriculture could complete the environmental study and reconsider approval of the genetically engineered beets. The environmental groups that brought the lawsuit argued that genetically modified beets would contaminate unmodified crops grown nearby by organic farmers and others who chose to plant conventional seeds.
Sugar beet growers sold the 2007-8 crop for about $1.335 billion, according to U.S.D.A. data.